, 5-4.
| event |
round |
table |
player one |
result |
player two |
| Grand Prix Columbus 2010 | 12 | 31 | Chapin, Patrick (1886) | Won 2-1 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (1900) |
| Grand Prix Kansas City 2011 | 5 | 84 | Chapin, Patrick (1928) | Lost 1-2 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (1980) |
| Grand Prix Pittsburgh 2011 | 12 | 17 | Chapin, Patrick (1928) | Won 2-1 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (2008) |
| Grand Prix San Antonio 2012 | 7 | 30 | Chapin, Patrick (1834) | Lost 1-2 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (2035) |
| Grand Prix Albuquerque 2013 | 7 | 112 | Chapin, Patrick (1954) | Lost 1-2 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (1981) |
| Pro Tour Journey into Nyx | 9 | 68 | Chapin, Patrick (1923) | Won 2-1 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (1953) |
| Pro Tour Journey into Nyx | S | | Chapin, Patrick (2006) | Won 2-0 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (1993) |
| Grand Prix Seattle-Tacoma 2015 | 5 | 81 | Chapin, Patrick (2161) | Won 2-1 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (1938) |
| Pro Tour Amonkhet | 9 | 73 | Chapin, Patrick (1816) | Lost 0-2 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (2018) |