| event | round | table | player one | result | player two |
| Pro Tour Philadelphia 2011 | S | Utter-Leyton, Josh (2121) | Won 3-2 | Black, Samuel (1935) | |
| Grand Prix Charleston 2012 | 4 | 49 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (2073) | Won 2-0 | Black, Samuel (1731) |
| 2014 World Championship | 4 | 4 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (1739) | Won 2-0 | Black, Samuel (2003) |
| Pro Tour Dragons of Tarkir | 8 | 34 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (1965) | Won 2-1 | Black, Samuel (2143) |
| 2017 World Championship | 12 | 3 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (2078) | Won 2-1 | Black, Samuel (2050) |