, 5-4-1.
| event |
round |
table |
player one |
result |
player two |
| Grand Prix Kansas City 2008 | 9 | 33 | Black, Samuel (1565) | Lost 0-2 | Thompson, Gerry (1930) |
| 2008 World Championship | 10 | 1 | Black, Samuel (1730) | Won 2-1 | Thompson, Gerry (2016) |
| Grand Prix Nashville 2010 | 4 | 492 | Black, Samuel (1796) | Won 2-0 | Thompson, Gerry (1909) |
| Pro Tour Dark Ascension | 16 | 12 | Black, Samuel (1988) | ID | Thompson, Gerry (1987) |
| Pro Tour Magic Origins | 13 | 11 | Black, Samuel (2118) | Lost 1-2 | Thompson, Gerry (1959) |
| Pro Tour Battle for Zendikar | 12 | 25 | Black, Samuel (2015) | Won 2-0 | Thompson, Gerry (2135) |
| Grand Prix Atlanta 2015 | 14 | 28 | Black, Samuel (1996) | Won 2-0 | Thompson, Gerry (2133) |
| Grand Prix Vancouver 2017 | 11 | 2001 | Black, Samuel (2017) | Lost 0-2 | Thompson, Gerry (2028) |
| 2017 World Championship | 14 | 4 | Black, Samuel (2052) | Won 2-0 | Thompson, Gerry (1995) |
| Pro Tour Dominaria | 2 | 180 | Black, Samuel (2024) | Lost 1-2 | Thompson, Gerry (2056) |