| event | round | table | player one | result | player two |
| Pro Tour Dark Ascension | 9 | 62 | Martell, Tom (1960) | Won 2-1 | Costa, Matthew (1925) |
| Grand Prix Indianapolis 2012 | 8 | 9 | Martell, Tom (1989) | Won 2-0 | Costa, Matthew (2121) |
| Pro Tour Theros | 15 | 42 | Martell, Tom (1989) | Won 2-0 | Costa, Matthew (2086) |