, 4-2.
| event |
round |
table |
player one |
result |
player two |
| Grand Prix Columbus 2010 | 11 | 9 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (1917) | Lost 0-2 | Martell, Tom (1951) |
| Grand Prix Austin 2012 | 14 | 34 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (2144) | Won 2-1 | Martell, Tom (1924) |
| 2013 World Championship | 4 | 7 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (1970) | Won 2-1 | Martell, Tom (2028) |
| 2013 World Championship | 8 | 4 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (2005) | Won 2-1 | Martell, Tom (2012) |
| 2014 World Championship | 3 | 6 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (1718) | Won 2-1 | Martell, Tom (1864) |
| Pro Tour Shadows over Innistrad | 4 | 189 | Utter-Leyton, Josh (1843) | Lost 0-2 | Martell, Tom (1801) |